Outrage Part II

You can tell your friends, you read this story on Frankly Speaking before it hit the Associated Press.

Earlier, I wrote a post about Len and Terry Bernardo who have been threatened by the Division of Human Rights in the State of New York for playing Christian music as well as advertising for the “Christian skate.” But not only have they been notified, but the newspaper that ran their ad has been informed that it may be guilty of aiding and abetting the so-called “discrimination.”

I interviewed Terry today about how it all got started. At this point, all she can guess is that someone complained to the Human Rights Division, although she does not know for sure. She said she received an anonymous e-mail that warned her she better get a lawyer. It didn’t make sense until she received a letter from the HRD.

Terry is emphatic that they do not discriminate at her business. Anyone is allowed to skate according to Terry. “You don’t have to say you love Jesus to get in,” said Terry. She said any one and every one is welcome. She said that she and her husband just wanted to provide a night where the music is of the “Christian genre.”

“It’s just billboard Christian music,” she said.

Terry says that the Associated Press contacted her today. Also, Terry and her husband have been contacted by Jay Sekulow of the American Center for Law and Justice. Sekulow has expressed an interest in meeting the couple, according to Terry.

In the letter faxed to me by Terry Bernardo, the Division of Human Rights claims that Skate Time 209’s advertisement that announces a “Christian Skate” “clearly seeks the patronage of Christian skaters and apparently denies or at a minimum discourages non-Christian patronage, constitutes a prima facie violation of Human Rights Law 296.2(a) (Executive Law, Art. 15) This statute provides:

2. (a) It shall be an unlawful discriminatory practice for any person, being the owner, lessee, proprietor, manager, superintendent agent or employee of any place of public accommodation, resort or amusement, because of the race, creed, color, national origin, sexual orientation, military status, sex, or disability or marital status of any person, directly or indirectly, to refuse, withhold from or deny to such person any of the accommodations, advantages, facilities or privileges thereof,…”

The letter threatens the Ulster County Press by stating “Furthermore, a newspaper which publishes advertisements which express unlawful discrimination pursuant to Human Rights law can be charged with “aiding and abetting” such unlawful discrimination pursuant to Human Rights Law 296.6.”

Terry Bernardo said that they changed the ad to read “spiritual” instead of Christian and were told that it still wasn’t acceptable, that it was “a moot point.”

I am shocked at where we have come in this country. Based on this logic and this law, bars could not host “Ladies Night,” county fairs couldn’t host “Senior Day” or “Kids Night”, and heck, Shoney’s couldn’t have “Mother’s Day with free strawberry pie for Mom.”

Terry’s understanding from the HRD is that by designating a skate with Christian music, that people who do not like Christian music are discouraged from coming in. The skates were scheduled for Sunday afternoons between 1 and 4PM.
Terry said that she just wants the case to go away, that she doesn’t want to fight. But she also says she hasn’t done anything discriminatory and that she will do what she needs to do to protect her business. Terry and her husband Len, were prepared to retire. Instead of doing so, they decided to operate a skating rink for the community and for fun.

I feel badly that Terry and Len are having to go through this situation. I offer them prayers and hopes of courage.

If they should find themselves on the losing end of this situation, all I can say is that freedom in America is surely dwindling away.

UPDATE: Here is a link to a small AP story about the issue. The story includes a survey for you.

(Note as well: I asked the Bernardo’s if they receive any government grants or tax dollars.  Terry said “no.”  She said they privately own their skating rink business.)

5 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Terry – I certainly wasn’t implying earlier that you were being irresponsible. I was hoping two things: 1) that this was a hoax, because it is so ridiculous, and 2) that you were going to do some more digging on the story.

It’s beginning to smell like a real story. I really would be interested in more context to this story. Not saying that these people aren’t being hounded, but are we hearing everything here? If so, then everyone from the ACLU to the American Center for Law and Justice should be involved.

I’ve just heard stories like this before that are more spin than fact. Thanks for doing follow-up. I’ll be very interested to hear more.

John–Not a problem. Perhaps I sounded too defensive in my response to you–if so, I apologize. And I can understand your reservations about such a story. There are so many hoaxes out there and often the tendency is to ramp up the rhetoric.

If there are any other facts you’d like to know just let me know. What I know is that the skating rink owners ran ads in the paper advertising their rink. One of the ads adverstised a “Christian Skate.”

On June 15, 2006, the Division of Human Rights sent a letter to the CEO of Skate Time 209 (that would be Terry and Len) and the CEO of the Ulster County Press.

I’ll scan the letter in and offer to you as a PDF file so that you may view it.

To summarize, the Division of Human Rights is claiming that this “Christian Skate” is discriminatory.

In that letter, there are no enclosures, no claims made that non-Christians weren’t allowed to skate, etc., only the claim that the Bernardo’s act of merely advertising a “Christian Skate” is discriminatory.

I asked Terry Bernardo if her skating rink accepts public or tax payer funds or grants. She said “no” that they are a privately owned business.

I’m with you John, that it sounds unreal. Unfortunately it is real.

After reading about this some more, i just want to say: Good catch!

I wrote about this as well and referenced you. We come from different places politically, but I’d like to think that lunacy and discrimination are scorned by reasonable people of all ’stripes’.

thanks again..

Just a thought

Correct me if I am wrong

They adverstised it as “Christian Skate Night”

I believe in the Bible, I believe in the Constitution for Freedom of Relgion, I believe in the Civil Rights.

If this is a private business that has ONE night dedicated for Christians I see no problems, if you are not a Christian then do not go on that night, go another night or to another skating rink

I read some where that a majority of Americans say they beleive in a God, so then why does the minority try to tell others that it is unfair to practive what we beleive and at times enjoy it and have fun. Do they not have there time to tell others about there beliefs and have fun in the manner they want too

Some people like to make trouble when there is none

I see nothing wrong with a Christian Skate night

Terry, Bryant Park advertizes a Fete de Noel every winter in New York City. Noel is a Christian word which means a carol about Jesus’s birth. If the Division of Human Rights are going after the Bernados, they will also have to close down Bryant Park skating as well, otherwise they will be guilty of discriminating against a small business.



Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)